The Indianapolis Colts are in the middle of a critical training camp with plenty of questions surrounding the quarterback tilt between Anthony Richardson Sr. and Daniel Jones . After back-to-back nine and eight-win seasons, fans are ready for more success like the team had in the 2000s. Indy’s most illustrious names were on the squad during that span, and Sports Illustrated’s Monday Morning Quarterback staff placed seven Colts names on the All-Quarter Century Team (2000-2025). The ranks include first, second, and third-team tiers, along with honorable mentions. Starting off the list is a name nobody should be surprised by, and a quarterback who shaped what success means for the Colts’ franchise.